Compensation Calculation: How to Determine Employee Salaries

Employee compensation plays a critical role in hiring, retention, budgeting, and long-term business growth. Beyond choosing the right salary range, building competitive pay structures involves balancing market trends, employee expectations, internal equity, and legal compliance. 

In this guide, we’ll explore how small businesses can determine employee salaries, create structured compensation strategies, and attract talent through both financial and non-financial rewards.

What goes into employee compensation?

Employee compensation includes all the financial and non-financial rewards employees receive in exchange for their work. The foundation is a base salary or hourly wage that provides consistent pay for performing job responsibilities. Many employers also offer bonuses and incentives, such as commissions, profit-sharing, or performance-based rewards, to recognize achievements and motivate productivity.

Benefits are another major component of compensation and may include health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, dental and vision coverage, and tuition reimbursement. Compensation can also extend beyond direct pay to include equity, stipends, and other forms of support that contribute to employees’ overall financial well-being.

Non-monetary perks can also play an important role in attracting and retaining talent. Flexible schedules, remote or hybrid work options, professional development opportunities, wellness programs, and career advancement pathways can improve employee satisfaction and strengthen workplace culture while complementing traditional financial compensation.

Conduct a job analysis before setting pay

Before setting salary ranges, businesses should conduct a thorough job analysis to ensure compensation aligns with the role’s responsibilities, required qualifications, and market value. This process also supports fair and competitive pay practices, which can improve recruitment, retention, and employee satisfaction.

When determining pay,  evaluate both internal job expectations and external salary benchmarks to ensure compensation reflects the complexity and demands of the position. Without a detailed analysis, companies risk underpaying employees, losing talent to competitors, or creating pay inequities within the organization.

Key job analysis factors include:

• Job responsibilities: Roles with greater decision-making authority or complexity typically command higher pay.
• Required skills and certifications: Specialized expertise or technical knowledge often increases compensation.
• Experience level: Positions requiring extensive industry experience generally justify higher salary ranges.
• Education requirements: Advanced degrees or professional credentials can raise earning potential.
• Market demand: High-demand roles may require more competitive pay to attract qualified candidates.
• Geographic location: Cost of living and regional labor markets influence compensation expectations.

[Read more: Upskilling Existing Employees Could Address Hiring Challenges, Research Finds]

Use the best tools for salary benchmarking

Salary benchmarking tools help businesses compare their compensation packages against current market rates, making it easier to attract and retain qualified employees. By analyzing salary data across industries, locations, and job types, these tools allow employers to build fair, competitive pay structures while avoiding underpaying or overspending on talent. Benchmarking also helps organizations improve hiring strategies, support pay transparency, and adapt compensation plans as labor market conditions change.

Using reliable benchmarking resources gives businesses access to real-time compensation insights and broader industry trends. Common salary benchmarking tools include:

• Glassdoor: Provides salary estimates based on employee-reported compensation data, offering businesses insight into pay trends, benefits, and company comparisons.
• Payscale: Delivers compensation data and salary reports tailored by industry, role, education, experience, and geographic location.
• Salary.com: Offers detailed salary ranges, compensation planning tools, and market analysis resources for employers.
• LinkedIn Salary: Uses member-submitted compensation information to provide insights into wages, bonuses, and regional pay trends.

Many businesses will combine multiple benchmarking tools to gain more accurate and balanced compensation data for decision-making.

How to set a pay range for each position

While exact numbers will vary, you can follow these steps to establish an equitable pay range for each role in your organization:

Conduct market research and evaluate comparable roles

Creating structured pay ranges begins with researching current market compensation data for similar positions. Compare salaries across your industry, geographic region, and company size to understand what competitors are offering. 

Salary ranges are typically built around a midpoint informed by market benchmarks, with minimum and maximum pay levels reflecting varying levels of experience and performance. 

Establish internal equity and experience levels

After gathering external salary data, evaluate your organization’s internal equity to ensure employees in similar roles are compensated fairly. Review job responsibilities, required skills, certifications, and reporting structures to group positions into consistent pay grades. 

Experience levels also influence placement within a range, with entry-level employees often starting near the minimum and highly experienced employees earning closer to the maximum. This salary range spreads allow businesses to account for employee growth, promotions, and performance progression over time. 

Align pay ranges with compensation strategy goals

Your pay ranges should support your organization’s broader compensation and business objectives. For example, companies focused on aggressive hiring may position salaries above market averages to attract talent quickly, while others may prioritize long-term retention through performance incentives and career development opportunities. Your compensation strategy should also account for budgeting, workforce planning, and organizational growth goals.

[Read more: 7 Effective Budgeting Strategies for Small Businesses]

Factor in non-salary compensation and benefits

Pay ranges should include more than base salary alone. Employers must also consider bonuses, retirement contributions, healthcare coverage, paid leave, flexible scheduling, wellness programs, and other perks that contribute to total compensation. Today’s employees increasingly evaluate overall compensation packages rather than salary alone — meaning that strong benefits and non-monetary perks can help businesses remain competitive even if they can’t offer the highest salaries in the market.

How to negotiate salary with employees and new hires

Whether you’re negotiating an initial salary for a prospective employee or discussing a raise with a current one, these tips can help both sides reach a mutually beneficial agreement:

Prepare with market data and compensation guidelines

Successful salary negotiations begin with preparation. Start by researching industry salary benchmarks, evaluating the role’s responsibilities, and establishing a realistic compensation range before discussions begin. HR leaders should enter negotiations with clear compensation guidelines and a strong understanding of the candidate’s value to the organization. This preparation process also helps companies maintain consistency and fairness across hiring and promotion decisions.

Communicate clearly and manage expectations

Open, transparent communication is essential during salary negotiations. As the employer, you should clearly explain how compensation decisions are made, including factors such as experience, skills, education, and internal pay structures. Candidates are more likely to respond positively when they understand the reasoning behind an offer. Make time to discuss opportunities for future raises, bonuses, or advancement to demonstrate your commitment to the employee’s long-term growth potential.

Stay flexible and consider total compensation

Successful negotiations often involve balancing employee expectations with organizational limitations while maintaining a respectful, collaborative approach. If an employee’s salary expectations exceed the company’s budget, consider negotiating through alternative forms of compensation, such as signing bonuses, additional paid time off, remote work flexibility, or professional development support. 

What to do when your salaries aren't competitive

When businesses can’t offer the highest salaries, they can still attract and retain employees by strengthening other aspects of the employee experience. Many candidates evaluate overall quality of life, growth potential, and workplace satisfaction alongside financial compensation. Companies that communicate a strong employee value proposition often remain competitive even with tighter salary budgets.

Alternative retention and recruitment strategies include:

• Enhanced benefits packages: Offering strong healthcare coverage, retirement contributions, wellness programs, or tuition assistance can increase the perceived value of compensation.
• Flexible work arrangements: Remote work, hybrid schedules, and flexible hours are highly valued by many employees and can improve work-life balance.
• Career development opportunities: Training programs, mentorship, certifications, skills development, and clear advancement paths help employees feel invested in their future. These should ideally be outlined in the employee handbook and communicated during onboarding, but also throughout an employee’s tenure.
• Positive workplace culture: Supportive leadership, recognition programs, and inclusive environments can improve morale and employee loyalty.
• Performance-based incentives: Bonuses, profit-sharing, or extra paid time off can reward employees without permanently increasing base salaries.

Businesses should also gather feedback from candidates and employees to understand why offers are declined or why turnover occurs. Identifying these patterns can help you refine your benefits, improve company culture, and better align compensation strategies with employee priorities. 

[Read more: 4 Low-Cost Ways to Reward Employees]

Know the legal requirements

Federal, state, and local laws can all influence how employers structure salaries, overtime policies, and pay transparency standards.

Key legal considerations include:

• Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA): The FLSA, enforced by the U.S. Department of Labor, establishes federal rules for minimum wage, overtime pay, recordkeeping, and child labor standards. Employers must properly classify employees as exempt or nonexempt to ensure overtime compliance.
• Pay equity and discrimination laws: The Equal Pay Act states that employers cannot pay employees differently based on protected characteristics such as sex, race, or ethnicity when workers perform substantially equal work. Conducting regular pay equity audits can help businesses identify and address disparities.
• Salary transparency laws: Many states now require employers to disclose salary ranges in job postings or during hiring conversations. Pay transparency laws continue expanding across states and municipalities, so you’ll need to research regulations where your business operates and where your employees or candidates are based. 

Because compensation laws differ significantly by jurisdiction, you should regularly review state and local requirements and consult legal or HR professionals to ensure ongoing compliance.

Jamie Johnson contributed to this article.

CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.

CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.