Everything You Need to Know About Hiring an SEO Agency for Your Small Business

Search engine optimization (SEO) firms offer a range of digital services, from basic research to strategy execution. With their help, your website can rank for local and standard search queries, resulting in more web traffic. However, capabilities differ among SEO agencies, and less reputable firms may make unrealistic promises or use outdated tactics.

By asking the right questions and researching SEO companies, you can weed out unsavory firms and better understand your needs. Use the following questions to spark conversations with your team and evaluate potential partners.

Decide what tasks you need help with before hiring an SEO agency

Think about your goals and what you want to accomplish. Then consider which tasks you can do in-house with paid or free SEO tools, and which you want to outsource. To put your needs in perspective, look at your monthly budget and internal resources. For instance, if you plan to manage SEO content in-house, determine if your team has the right skills and time.

Many SEO agencies assist with the following:

• SEO strategy.
• Pay-per-click (PPC) advertising.
• Voice search optimization.
• SEO audit.
• User experience optimization.
• SEO research on key words and competitors.
• Technical SEO.
• Local SEO and citation management.
• Link building.
• SEO content.
• Digital marketing services.

Although many agencies will handle your optimization efforts from start to finish, SEO is a two-way street. Your company should be prepared to continue with SEO after the firm finishes. Ensure your team knows basic SEO terms, metrics, and strategies. 

Questions for vetting SEO agencies and consultants

Dig into the background of every SEO firm you consider. Check third-party review sites and Reddit communities to see what people say about the agency. While researching companies, note any gaps that require more detail and ask these questions during interviews. For example, the agency may not disclose what tools it uses or the price range. 

Does the SEO service provider have a good reputation?

Be wary of any firm that lacks an online presence or receives tons of negative reviews. Do your due diligence by checking out social media channels and review sites. Consider asking for recommendations from industry or local networking groups. Also, look at the firm's website and request recent case studies (within the last three years).

Is the SEO firm transparent?

Reputable firms will disclose their processes and techniques, including providing a list of deliverables you can expect. If they say this information is proprietary, consider it a red flag. Secretive strategies could mean that the agency uses less-savory methods that Google frowns upon. The company should also tell you what a successful campaign looks like and estimate how long it will take to reach various goals.

Does the agency use ethical practices?

Failure to follow best practices for SEO can result in your website being penalized. The firm should understand Google Search Essentials (formerly Webmaster Guidelines) and be forthcoming about various techniques. For example, SEO companies shouldn't pay for backlinks or use private blog networks (PBNs). Hidden content for the purpose of manipulating search engines is also a big no-no.

What technologies does the SEO firm use?

Many firms use paid and free SEO software, including key word trackers and backlink checkers, to measure and monitor your progress. Ask SEO agencies if they provide an online portal, offer assistance choosing technologies, or disclose the tools they use. Look for easy-to-use online dashboards that let you track website traffic and see progress without waiting for a monthly report. 

What happens after your contract ends?

Many contracts last six months to one year. But search engine optimization is an ongoing process that continues long after your agreement with an SEO specialist ends. Along with reading the fine print of your contract (including any guarantees that your website will be optimized), ask the firm how they handle agreement terminations and whether they help your team during the transition process.

Questions to ask for local SEO, e-commerce SEO, and content SEO needs

The primary goals and key strategies differ between local, e-commerce, and content SEO. Local SEO drives foot traffic and bookings, while e-commerce SEO helps small stores rank for product searches. On the other hand, content SEO establishes your site’s authority, builds brand awareness, and optimizes a mix of informational and investigative key words. Ask the following questions to learn how an agency can help with your specific SEO needs.

How does the agency optimize for local search results?

Look for firms with experience in local SEO for small businesses. They should discuss local link-building strategies, like nearby partnerships or public relations opportunities, and NAP consistency, meaning your name, address, and phone number are the same across your Google Business Profile, website, and third-party business directories. 

Does the SEO firm optimize your Google Business Profiles?

Google instructs agencies on client account management. You keep control of digital assets but add the SEO firm as a profile manager or agency, which allows them to handle routine tasks. SEO companies often update your profile, publish posts, reply to reviews, and protect your listing from spam. 

An optimized Google business profile is like a free marketing engine. It collects key word–rich reviews and gives people all the information they need to find your business and purchase goods or services.  

How do you consider AEO and GEO?

Modern SEO firms build answer engine optimization (AEO) and generative engine optimization (GEO) into their strategies. AEO helps websites win local map packs, featured snippets, and direct SERP answers. In comparison, GEO improves visibility on conversational AI platforms like ChatGPT and Claude. It optimizes content so AI tools are more likely to cite and recommend it. 

Since AEO and GEO build on traditional SEO, a good SEO agency focuses on foundational tasks while ensuring your content is formatted so AI can access it. This step involves verifying content, answering common questions, and implementing schema markup for step-by-step guides, company information, and FAQs.

How does the agency improve your online store’s search performance? 

Look for firms with experience in e-commerce SEO. Their approach should prioritize revenue generation by focusing on clicks that drive purchases. Many address technical issues first. This step improves website accessibility and mobile responsiveness. 

They add structured data so that product prices and customer ratings appear in search results. In addition, your e-commerce key word strategy should capture traffic from high-converting terms rather than focusing solely on high-volume phrases.

What SEO content deliverables should I expect monthly?

Get a clear breakdown of what deliverables you’ll receive each month. They should outline how many pieces of content you’ll get per category (blog posts, graphics, or landing pages). Also, request the expected word count per deliverable and the number of included revisions. Ask agencies if they generate content with AI or have writers with specific industry experience. 

What's their reporting process like?

Discuss reporting cadence and metrics with SEO firms. Typically, agencies provide monthly updates on organic traffic improvements, backlink counts, and search engine rankings for high-priority key words. Reports show progress toward goals, measure your campaign’s performance, and highlight next steps.

In the age of AI, many firms also include core AEO/GEO metrics, such as how often AI tools cite your URL, what percentage of queries earned a featured snippet spot, and how many visitors these platforms refer to your site. Request a sample report, then ask agencies how the metrics would differ based on your business goals.

How to evaluate SEO pricing contracts and expected timelines

Professional estimates for basic SEO services range from $500 to $2,500 monthly. According to Ahrefs, small businesses “typically need at least a four-figure monthly budget to work with a reputable SEO agency.” Those with leaner budgets may find greater value in working with an SEO consultant rather than a larger firm. 

In addition, specialty campaigns generally cost more because they involve several types of SEO (on-page, off-page, technical, and local) and content. These services are more hands-on, with many firms offering a dedicated success manager.  

SEO pricing models include:

• Monthly retainer: SEO agencies often offer one, three, six, and 12-month plans. Some firms discount fees when you enter into a longer contract. With tiered pricing, small businesses can choose basic, mid-level, or enterprise services. 
• Project-based pricing: This pricing model outlines expectations in a contract, including specs for deliverables, such as a specific number of words or backlinks for optimized content. The one-time cost can be high, depending on the tasks involved.
• Hourly consulting rate: Although less common, some independent SEO consultants may advise your business for an hourly rate. This method may be less expensive than other pricing models, but Semrush doesn’t recommend it for teams new to SEO or startup companies. 

SEO proposals should include pricing, clear deliverables and timelines, a list of key performance indicators, details about their team, an explanation of how their services address your problems and help you reach your goals, and what sets their agency apart from competitors. 

SEO timelines

The age of your domain, the level of competition, and the type of SEO strategy you use affect your timeline. Implementing local SEO for a brick-and-mortar business may yield results faster than building awareness nationally for an e-commerce shop. Likewise, if your website is brand new, it can take up to a year to build authority, while sites with a two-year digital footprint may see results in six months. 

Ask firms to break down how they’ll spend their time each month and how this differs across stages. For example, when ramping up efforts, the team may dedicate 10 hours to editing and optimizing content, five hours to technical auditing, and eight hours to key word research. 

Standard SEO stages include:

• Months one and two: Most small businesses don’t see a big difference in the beginning. Agencies perform technical audits, conduct key word research, optimize existing web pages, set up tracking, and resolve crawl errors.
• Months three and four: Established websites may see more impressions, higher click-through rates, and organic traffic. During this phase, SEO firms publish new content, optimize metadata, and build backlinks.
• Months five and six: Website visibility increases across the board, resulting in consistent organic lead or sales generation. Agencies continue building links, use data to adjust their strategies, and expand high-performing content clusters.
• Months six through 12: Small businesses can expect organic traffic and leads to increase. SEO companies improve your website’s user experience, perform a competitor analysis, and continue to build out your content. 

CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.

CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.