AI in HR: How Small Businesses Can Use Automation to Boost Efficiency Without Losing Human Expertise

After building a career in human resources across multiple industries, Amy Boston founded Threology, an HR consulting firm that helps organizations navigate hiring, compliance, employee relations, and workplace strategy. Throughout her time in the field, she has kept a close eye on the development of AI and its impact on company operations.

Today, Boston views artificial intelligence as one of the biggest opportunities available to small businesses. In a market with nail-biting competition, lean teams need to have access to the same efficiencies and resources often reserved for larger organizations. From automating administrative work to generating insights more quickly, AI can accomplish more with fewer resources.

At the same time, she believes lived experience and expertise cannot be replaced. While AI tools can focus on other priorities, they lack the context, empathy, and perspective needed to navigate the human side of business.

Here is what Boston had to say about AI's growing role in HR and the future of work.

Embrace technology and develop AI literacy 

Many business owners are uncertain about what the future of AI will bring. Still, Boston argues that resisting the technology does not make things easier. “We cannot be afraid, and it doesn't give you any leg up by ignoring it," she says. 

If you have already embraced an AI-centric future, it is important not to assume immediate proficiency without first developing fluency in how to use these tools effectively. The decision to adopt AI is more nuanced than just opening a chatbot and receiving perfect results. As Boston points out, it is a matter of understanding the right questions to ask, acknowledging potential biases, and knowing when to defer to human expertise. 

Level the playing field for small businesses

Oftentimes, large companies have entire teams dedicated to HR responsibilities, a luxury not available to every business. They may have specialists focused on payroll, data analysis, training, compliance, process improvement, and more. For small business owners, those responsibilities fall on just a few employees—and in many cases, a single person.

According to Boston, AI can help bridge that gap. By systemizing routine work, small businesses can move with much greater efficiency and accomplish more without significantly expanding headcount. Rather than spending hours on menial backend tasks, employees can devote their attention to other pressing matters.  

Finding the best places to integrate AI 

Just as Excel did not replace accountants and calculators did not remove the need for arithmetic, AI is best understood as a system for handling repetitive tasks so professionals can focus on strategy, relationships, and problem-solving.

In HR, processes such as payroll processing, onboarding checklists, and template creation are particularly well-suited for AI because they are predictable and follow clear rules.

Keep humans involved in critical decisions

AI alone cannot manage your hiring. There are times when it may be appropriate to implement AI to organize applications or identify qualifications, but final decisions should always involve human review. 

There are also risks associated with using AI for compliance-related matters. Employment laws vary based on location, workforce size, and numerous other factors. If you rely on a generic AI response for an employee handbook or legal requirement, there could be big problems. 

The bottom line is that subjective, high-stakes processes should be kept outside of AI-assisted decision-making. 

Be skeptical of AI-generated answers

One of the biggest misconceptions about AI, Boston says, is that confidence equals accuracy. AI often presents information in a polished and authoritative way, even when the content is incomplete or incorrect. Because of this, business owners should verify information rather than accept it at face value.

Boston encourages leaders to treat AI as a useful assistant rather than an expert advisor. If an answer seems questionable, it deserves a second look.

Invest in the next generation of workers

Looking ahead, Boston emphasizes the importance of less experienced employees continuing to build foundational skills. AI should not replace the early-career experiences that help shape a strong professional base. Often, the entry-level tasks serve as training grounds for understanding core business operations. As technology takes on more of that work, companies will need to rethink how they approach training.

For business owners, this means balancing efficiency with education. While AI may complete tasks faster, employees still need opportunities to develop personal expertise and critical thinking skills. This supports business continuity and ensures a strong succession pipeline.

CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.

CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.