If you could create your own fantasy board of directors, who would be on it? CO— connects you with thought leaders from across the business spectrum and asks them to help solve your biggest business challenges. In this edition, we ask an entrepreneur for advice on how to turn positive experiences into customer reviews and referrals.
In this edition of “Ask the Board,” we feature Liz Benditt, Founder and President of The Balm Box, an Overland Park, Kansas company that designs and ships research-backed, treatment-specific care packages for people navigating cancer.
Benditt explains that most small business owners think about reviews backwards. They treat them like a marketing tactic or something to collect and display rather than a signal of how well you're actually serving your customers.
However, the businesses with the best reviews aren't the ones with the most aggressive follow-up sequences. They're the ones that earn reviews by delivering something worth talking about. Here's how to build a strategy that works from the inside out:
Start with the product, not the ask
No review strategy in the world can fix a mediocre customer experience. Before you spend a single hour optimizing your follow-up emails, ask yourself honestly: Is what I'm delivering genuinely worth five stars?
The Balm Box has built its entire product line from direct patient and caregiver research or 500+ conversations about what actually helps someone going through cancer treatment, not what's assumed to help. That foundation means customers arrive at the review moment already delighted. The ask is almost secondary. If your reviews are disappointing, the answer is rarely a better email subject line. Start by looking at the product.
Test your timing obsessively
When you ask matters as much as how you ask. The Balm Box tested review request timing at three intervals: at delivery, three days post-delivery, and seven days post-delivery. The winner wasn't the one we expected and finding it moved our response rate significantly.
Every review is a direct line to what your customers are actually thinking and feeling, and you never know where your next great idea, insight, or product improvement is hiding.Liz Benditt, Founder and President of The Balm Box
The right timing varies by product, by customer, and by how long it takes someone to actually experience what you've sent them. Don't assume. Test it, measure it, and let the data tell you when your customers are most ready to share.
Make the ask feel personal, not automated
The Balm Box’s customers are going through one of the hardest experiences of their lives. A generic "Rate us!" email doesn't land and can even feel tone-deaf. That’s why the company tested message tone and found that briefly, genuinely acknowledging what customers are navigating dramatically improved our response rates.
This principle applies beyond our niche: People can tell the difference between a message designed for a person and one designed for a list. Even a small, authentic gesture, such as using someone's name, referencing what they ordered, or acknowledging why they came to you signals that you see them as a customer, not a conversion. That shift in tone can move your response rates more than any subject line optimization will.
Read every review with fresh eyes
The most underused part of any review strategy isn't the collection, it's the reading. Every review is a direct line to what your customers are actually thinking and feeling, and you never know where your next great idea, insight, or product improvement is hiding.
By simply reading its reviews carefully and consistently, The Balm Box has found genuine product feedback, new use cases it hasn't considered, and powerful language for its own marketing. Treat reviews as qualitative research, not a score to maintain.
The businesses that use reviews as a feedback loop, not just a social proof tool are the ones that keep improving the product, which feeds the next round of great reviews.
CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.
CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.
Enroll today!
Sign up for Small Business B(AI)sics, our free AI training course, designed for small businesses like yours. Learn the basics of AI in just 30 minutes, plus get resources to help you apply AI skills at your business today.