A Complete Guide to Creating a Product Prototype

If you’re a small business owner looking to refine your product or service before the official launch, prototyping is an invaluable tool. It allows you to gather feedback and identify issues before your product is available to the public.

In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know to create and test prototypes successfully.

Key considerations before you start prototyping

Creating a prototype is a serious investment that requires forethought. Understanding the factors that matter the most for your business can ensure a strong prototype launch that will pay dividends in the long run.

Goals

Start by identifying the primary goals of your prototype. Do you need a proof of concept, or are you looking for feedback? Do you need to see how your product would function in reality? Are you looking to demonstrate the value of your idea to investors? Understanding your goals helps to streamline the process and focus your budget.

Audience needs 

By researching your target audience to understand how your product can make their lives easier — and what your competitors may overlook — you strengthen your prototype’s ability to set your business apart. Ask yourself: What need are you trying to fill? What elements can you add to your prototype to set it apart from similar options on the market?  

Budget

Depending on your industry, production costs can vary widely. Knowing your budget will inform what manufacturers you contact, the materials you use, and even how you choose to ship it. It’s important not only to consider the final dollar amount, but also a breakdown of how much money will go toward materials, labor, and other development costs.

Functionality 

Building a prototype allows you to see the product you imagined come to life. Once it’s built, assess: Does it function the way you expected? What shortcomings may you not have anticipated? Will the needed improvements make it too costly for market expectations? A prototype in your hands or those of your test group answers these questions so you can take the next steps with confidence.

Manufacturing

When you begin drafting the plan for your prototype, it’s prudent to consider your manufacturing partner early. Are you planning to manufacture your product in the U.S., or will you have an international manufacturer? Depending on the answer, you face a different set of challenges. You’ll also want to consider your final product. If you aren’t making the product yourself, will the manufacturing company you partner with be able to handle the volume you require?

Shipping

Researching the shipping methods available to you, either domestic or foreign, is a key part of the prototype process. The shipping method you choose affects the price your customer will pay and their overall experience. By seeking out all available options, you can compare prices and methods and find a logistics partner who will ensure your customer’s experience is positive.

[Read more: 5 Services That Will Help You Save On Shipping Costs]

Legal protections 

When planning for a new product, considering patents, trademarks, NDAs, and other legal aspects is as important as the product itself. Crafting legal protections alongside your prototype helps safeguard your intellectual property and keep proprietary methods out of the public domain.

How to create a product prototype

If you’re creating a working prototype for a product, follow these steps to help the ideation and execution run smoothly: 

Define your concept

Research is crucial to turning your ideas into a working prototype. Draw an initial design that can then be moved to a virtual model. This will allow you to determine if you’ll need outside help. If so, a solid virtual design allows you to walk into your manufacturer with a clear goal in mind, streamlining the process of reaching a deliverable.

Select your prototype fidelity

Next, consider how closely you want your prototype to resemble your final product. Are you looking for a rough proof of concept, or are you to the point of testing the appearance, materials, and performance of what you hope to be your final product? Simple methods, such as cardboard models or 3D prints, help you visualize early ideas. High-fidelity prototypes allow you to test how your final product could function in clients' hands.

Create your initial model

Your proof-of-concept model lets you see your product's functionality under real-world conditions, especially through high-fidelity iterations. This model will allow you to test how various components work together. As you observe it, ask yourself if it’s functioning as intended and where there’s room for improvement.

Refine based on feedback

If you’re using a focus group, it’s important to take their feedback seriously. They’re the voice of your future clients, and refining your product based on what didn’t work will help ensure your final version succeeds.

How to create a service prototype

What if your prototype isn’t a physical item, but an experience? A service prototype allows you to map out and test how your business performs for potential clients or investors. Instead of going into opening day simply hoping your protocols work, a service prototype allows you to simulate:

• Customer experience. Take a focus group through the full customer journey to identify what’s working and what could be improved.
• Workflows. Simulating a complete workday with your staff allows you to pinpoint potential weak points.
• Service interactions: Testing your interactions helps your crew become familiar with the correct responses and protocols to put guests at ease.
• Emergency protocols. Simulating worst-case scenarios shows potential investors that you know how to keep clients and staff safe should an emergency strike.

In addition to soft-launch days, service prototypes can take many forms, including roleplay, desktop walkthroughs, and video prototyping. Service prototypes, when executed properly, can instill confidence in your workforce and investors so your clients are taken care of from day one.

[Read more: Quiz: How Good Is Your Customer Service? And How to Improve It]

How to build a prototype testing plan

Many business owners expect their prototype to be close to the finished product because of the amount of time and energy invested, but this is often not the case. To get the most from your prototype, test it in multiple stages to gather actionable feedback and refine your product or service. Proper testing allows you to validate your designs and continue moving forward with confidence.

Set a hypothesis and prepare your test questions or scenarios

The initial hypothesis of your prototype, be it a product or service, is simply a launching point. It’s important to expose all areas of your business to feedback. You want to know what clients or investors think of everything, down to the smallest aspects like fonts, copy, and messaging. Questions should encourage discussion to bring to light things you may not have considered.

Thoughtful scenarios that showcase a typical experience are an excellent tool for exposing weak points in your business that you may not have considered. This might involve asking testers to put your product through a typical use cycle or bringing them on-site for a full service experience.

Run a trial and use feedback to iterate on your prototype

Once your hypothesis is set, the experiment can begin. With each trial run, it’s important to pause, incorporate the feedback given, and reset the prototype. Having multiple iterations, questions, or scenarios also allows you to test from different angles. Ideally, you’ll have time for more than one test group, but even one trial can give you crucial insights for improving your product. With each prototype iteration, you can better cater to your desired demographic.

[Read more: How to Use AI to Test and Improve Your Business Idea]

Prototype costs and timelines

It’s important to set realistic expectations for your prototype’s cost and lead time. Underestimating the expenses or not giving yourself enough time to fully develop and test your product can lead to a poor outcome. While researching these things before you begin can help streamline this process, it’s still wise to err on the side of overestimating both your budget and timeline. Major cost and timeline factors include:

• Materials. The quality, scarcity, and source of materials can all lead to increased cost and extended production time.
• Manufacturer availability. Shorter deadlines can often increase the cost a manufacturer will charge.
• Design complexity. Intricate designs, numerous moving parts, and multi-component assemblies all require more labor. This often results in higher costs or longer build times.
• Technology used: Advanced methods like injection molding or 3D printing with high-end resins cost more than typical fabrication.
• Labor and expertise. If you require specialized designers, engineers, or technicians, you need to give yourself time to locate them and understand that hourly rates are often higher.
• Testing and certification. Depending on your industry, your prototype may require safety or compliance testing that can add fees to your budget and leave you waiting for certifications to be signed.
• Revisions and iterations. The need for multiple testing cycles and prototypes can extend timelines and drive up costs.

Understanding these factors upfront helps you plan your budget and timeline more accurately.

What to know before working with a third-party prototype developer 

If you aren’t crafting your prototype yourself, it’s important to ensure you’re protected legally. Trademarking or filing for a patent before approaching potential prototype developers safeguards you and allows the process to proceed smoothly. A reputable developer can be a strong partner in bringing your prototype to life because they have experience with both materials and processes.

As with any service you hire, ensure they meet your communication expectations and offer a portfolio of past projects and client reviews. This confirms they possess the expertise you need and can serve as a collaboration partner. Professional prototype development comes with increased costs as you’re paying for their experience, insight, and resources. Be sure to include their costs in your budget.  

With proper forethought, you can execute a smooth prototype development process that uncovers potential issues early and positions you ahead of your competitors.

Emily Heaslip contributed to this article.

CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.
 

CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.