When hiring employees for your small business, relying on someone’s résumé and performance in an interview isn’t enough. The ideal candidate should have the right mindset, communication skills, and professional and personal judgment to succeed in real-world situations.
To identify the best potential hires, you’ll need to ask thoughtful, intelligent questions during the interview. This guide breaks down key interview questions to ask your top candidates and the insights you’ll gain in the process.
Screen for product/company knowledge and prep quality
A candidate who’s truly interested in your organization and their potential role within it will have done their homework. Starting with questions that tap into company and product knowledge can quickly show whether they’ve taken the time to understand your business. These early questions also set the tone for the rest of the interview by signaling that preparation and attention to detail matter.
Look for responses that go beyond surface-level details. The candidate should be able to explain what your company does specifically, where your product or service fits into the market, and how their experience and interests align with that work. Vague or overly broad responses may suggest a lack of preparation for the interview, or a lack of genuine interest in the role and your organization.
Consider asking: What stood out to you most about our product/company?
Understand their process end-to-end
For sales roles, a strong candidate should be able to clearly explain how they approach each step of the sales cycle. Asking someone to walk through their sales process helps you understand how they think about prospecting and qualifying leads, building relationships, closing deals, and following up. It can also provide insights into how the individual prioritizes their time and measures success.
Here, listen for structure and consistency. This type of response suggests the candidate has developed a repeatable process, rather than relying on instinct or trial-and-error. At the same time, their response should also show some flexibility, allowing them to adjust to the customer or situation. A strong candidate is also likely to reference specific metrics, such as conversion rates or sales cycle length, and can explain how they use that data to adjust their approach over time.
This type of question also works for other industries or roles; even outside of sales, most positions involve some kind of repeatable workflow. A candidate’s process for their primary task—and their ability to articulate it clearly—can signal how that individual organizes their work, prioritizes tasks, and communicates with others.
Consider asking: Can you walk me through your sales process, from start to finish?
Test resilience and judgment
Setbacks and rejection can occur in nearly any industry, and may be especially prevalent in sales or other client-facing roles. Here, a resilient mindset and ability to bounce back from challenges are key. But persistence alone isn’t enough; a professional also needs the judgment to know when to move on or change direction. Questions in this domain should explore how the candidate evaluates opportunities, navigates hurdles, and makes decisions under pressure.
Listen to how the individual explains their decision-making process, especially in cases where priorities shifted or results didn’t turn out as planned. Did they continue or walk away—and why? Strong answers often include how the candidate assessed the likelihood of success, weighed competing priorities, and adjusted their approach in response to new information. This information can help you distinguish between thoughtful persistence and inefficient stubbornness.
DéVon Christopher Johnson, Chairman and CEO of BOMESI Foundation, suggests further exploring this by asking candidates to describe a situation in which they disagreed with a decision.
“This shows me how someone navigates authority, advocates for themselves, and exercises judgment under pressure,” explained Johnson. “That matters everywhere, but especially in fast-moving organizations.”
Consider asking: Tell me about a time when you faced a major setback at work. How did you handle the situation?
[Read more: Hiring Beyond the Resume: How to Hire for Soft Skills]
The best interviews feel like an honest exchange where both sides are figuring out if it’s the right fit.Anthony Mongiello, CEO and Founder of Formaggio Cheese
Evaluate relationship-building vs. new opportunity balance
In many roles, employees need to balance maintaining strong relationships with exploring new opportunities. In sales positions, this often involves managing a new lead pipeline alongside existing client relationships. In other industries, it may mean managing ongoing client work while prospecting for new business, or balancing retention efforts with new growth initiatives. Focusing too heavily on one area can limit long-term performance, especially in smaller teams where both sides matter.
Questions in this area should help you understand how candidates allocate their time, prioritize responsibilities, and manage competing demands. Strong answers will show how they nurture existing relationships while continuing to generate new opportunities. You’re also looking for signs of intentional planning, including how a candidate manages both short-term wins and longer-term growth.
Consider asking: How do you balance maintaining current client relationships with generating new opportunities?
Probe customer skills and scope management
Many roles require employees to navigate changing customer or stakeholder expectations—sometimes, in ways that don’t align with what’s realistic or feasible. The way a candidate handles these situations can directly affect both client outcomes and team dynamics.
Questions in this area should focus on the individual’s communication style, problem-solving skills, and ability to set boundaries. Strong candidates can demonstrate how they manage expectations clearly while maintaining trust and rapport. Internal collaboration is also important here, especially when solutions require input from multiple teams.
Consider asking: Tell me about a time you handled a request that went beyond what you or your team could deliver.
[Read more: 6 Steps to Building a Strong B2B Sales Team]
Ask for proof with behavioral questions
Behavioral questions are one of the most effective ways to validate what candidates have already told you. Rather than relying on hypothetical claims, these questions require candidates to describe specific situations, actions, and outcomes.
“Although all jobs are different, questions should be open-ended and behavior or situational-based to encourage responses that show you the person’s approach, decision-making, communication skills, and how that person responds to situations you know are required for your role,” said Suzette Schilling, Chief Human Resources Officer at EBG Solutions.
Weak answers tend to stay high-level, focusing on general responsibilities or team outcomes without clearly explaining the candidate’s individual role. Strong answers, on the other hand, walk through a specific situation, outline the actions taken, and highlight a clear result with measurable impact. The more detailed the answer, the easier it is to assess how their experience aligns with your needs.
In some cases, you may also need to go beyond conversation and into demonstration.
“For roles that require specific experience in a particular software tool, or specific technical skills, you do not have to take them at their word,” Schilling added. “You can make it part of the hiring process that all candidates must complete a short assignment to assess specific skills, and candidates should do it in front of you to ensure the work is done by your candidate.”
Consider asking: Can you walk me through a specific project or initiative you worked on, your role in it, and the results you achieved?
Assess motivation, growth mindset, and coachability
While a professional’s hard skills are important, their long-term success often depends on their motivation, willingness to learn, and openness to feedback. These traits shape not only how someone performs in their role, but how they contribute to a team over time.
That’s where cultural fit comes into play. As Johnson notes, it’s less about sameness and more about “values alignment and the capacity to evolve.”
When evaluating a candidate’s mindset, look for signs of self-awareness and curiosity. Strong candidates should be able to reflect on their experiences, identify areas for growth, and explain how they’ve adapted over time. Their answers should give you a sense of how they respond to feedback and how they approach long-term development.
“Culture is everything, especially in a business like ours where teamwork and pride in the product matter,” explained Anthony Mongiello, CEO and Founder of Formaggio Cheese. “You get a good sense pretty quickly if someone values collaboration, accountability, and craftsmanship or if they’re just looking for their next stop.”
Consider asking: What motivates you in your work?
[Read more: How a ‘Growth Mindset’ Helps You Handle Setbacks]
Close strong
The end of the interview is just as important as the beginning. Allowing candidates to ask questions can provide insight into their priorities, preparation, and level of interest in the role. The questions they ask can reveal how seriously they are evaluating the opportunity and whether they understand the expectations involved.
“The quality of someone’s questions often tells you more than their answers do,” emphasized Johnson.
This part of the conversation isn’t just about gathering information on your end, though. It also allows candidates to assess your organization and determine whether the role aligns with their professional goals.
“The best interviews feel like an honest exchange where both sides are figuring out if it’s the right fit,” said Mongiello.
How you close the interview reinforces that experience. Make sure candidates leave knowing what to expect, including next steps and a realistic timeline. A structured, respectful process not only leaves a lasting impression but can also give you the insights you need to make better hiring decisions.
Consider asking: What questions do you have about the role or organization?
CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.
CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.
