Every company wants the best talent, but recruiting top candidates with the required skills and experience you need can be challenging. Small businesses, in particular, face an uphill battle in recruiting employees, with factors like budget constraints and reduced brand visibility compared to larger competitors acting as headwinds. But this shouldn’t be a deterrent; it just means your recruitment process needs to be more intentional.
In this guide, we’ll explore changes your business can implement today to better attract and retain new talent.
Build a clear employer brand with consistent messaging
To get your brand noticed, you need to create an authentic brand with consistent messaging. Many candidates are wary of “bait-and-switch” job listings — in fact, 72% of candidates say a role they applied for didn’t match the one offered. Because of this incongruity, there’s a level of skepticism you need to overcome so the right candidates trust you and are interested in applying.
Counter this mistrust by developing your brand and ensuring that you have a consistent message that showcases your personality, highlights your “why,” and reinforces your company’s values. Align this messaging across all of your channels — your job listings, website, social media, interviews, and onboarding — so candidates know exactly what to expect. By gaining a complete understanding of the role, the company’s purpose, and how it makes a real impact, candidates are more likely to connect with your mission and join the team.
[Read more: How to Interview for Your Business]
Showcase your company culture everywhere
Your company culture reflects how your business lives out its values day to day, shaping how employees collaborate, communicate, and take accountability. Whether a candidate is browsing your website, scrolling through your social media, or reading a job description, your company culture should be clear and consistent across every touchpoint.
Visibility starts with defining your culture internally. When the culture is clearly defined, it creates shared expectations and helps teams work toward a common goal.
To showcase your culture, include employees’ voices across touchpoints such as testimonials, behind-the-scenes workplace videos, and real workplace stories. Doing so gives candidates an authentic picture of what it’s like to work at your company, helping attract talent who align with your values and ensuring a cultural fit.
Activate your current employees
Don’t overlook a valuable recruitment resource that’s right in front of you: your current employees. Here are some ways you can leverage your team for help.
Consider internal promotions before seeking outside candidates
Before seeking outside hires, consider whether any of your existing employees could be right for the role with targeted training, reskilling, or upskilling. Hiring from within is often faster — and more cost-effective — and investing in your existing talent can boost morale by demonstrating internal mobility.
[Read more: A Comprehensive Guide to Creating an Employee Training Program]
Don’t overlook a valuable recruitment resource that’s right in front of you: your current employees.
Ask your team for referrals
If you need to look outside the organization, ask your existing employees for input or referrals. Consulting your current employees with the talent acquisition process conveys respect, builds trust, and signals that you value their input.
Encourage employees' input by creating a referral program that rewards them with monetary or nonmonetary bonuses and recognition. This program can be structured however works best for your business. You may reward employees based on the number of referrals, whether you hire a referral, or another metric.
Reengage with former employees
Former employees who left your company on good terms may be candidates worth reconsidering. Known as boomerang employees — ex-employees who leave and later return to the same employer — these candidates can bring prior company experience and fresh ideas back to your table. That said, it’s important to ensure they’re fully committed to your business and are prepared to perform at a high level.
Offer competitive compensation, benefits, and flexible work arrangements
In a competitive job market, attracting and retaining talent requires offering a compensation package that meets today’s market expectations. What qualifies as “competitive” varies by role and location, but in most cases, you should aim to offer at least the local average salary for your open position or similar titles.
However, compensation isn’t the only factor candidates consider. For small businesses with limited budgets, comprehensive benefits packages tailored to employees’ needs can effectively demonstrate that you value their skills and contributions while making your business more attractive to candidates. Consider the benefits competitors are offering and survey your existing team to identify which ones would be most beneficial. These perks may include commuter benefits, a home office stipend, health or wellness benefits, and more.
Flexible work arrangements, including undefined schedules and hybrid or remote options, are another benefit that can make you a standout employer — and they remain highly sought after among candidates. In fact, data show that 40% of employees would take a pay cut to keep their remote jobs. As some companies push return-to-office policies, offering flexibility can set your business apart, support better work-life balance, and build autonomy and trust across teams.
Grow your talent pipeline
To attract and retain new talent, start by growing your talent pipeline. Here’s how you can get started today.
Create a talent database and nurture candidates
Regardless of whether you’re actively hiring, maintaining a searchable database of potential candidates can help you stay prepared for changing staffing needs. While you may not be looking to hire immediately, circumstances change in an instant, requiring you to fill a role quickly. By maintaining a talent database that includes key details such as skill set, pay range, prior experience, and availability, you’re already a step ahead in finding your next hire.
However, you need to nurture these leads and maintain contact to ensure they remain interested in the role, should you offer it. To do so, frequently engage with them through relevant, company-specific information, such as company updates, newsletters, or role-relevant insights. By keeping your business top of mind, you can ensure that candidates understand your culture and are aligned with your long-term goals.
Network with potential talent at industry events
Both in-person and virtual events bring together motivated, industry-focused professionals, creating a valuable opportunity to build connections that support long-term business growth. Most people attend these events to make meaningful connections — whether by building business relationships or exploring new career opportunities — making them especially valuable to employers seeking prospective candidates.
These events open the door to conversations with potential partners or collaborators who can expand your business and, in turn, increase your need for new talent. They also provide some insight into how others in your industry approach challenges, which may help you stay competitive in a changing market.
Build relationships with local higher education institutions
Tap into a network of eager, young candidates looking for work by partnering with higher education institutions in your area, such as through career fairs or university-run job boards. Partnering with colleges can help build a strong talent pipeline and connect you with a wealth of fresh, ready-to-train candidates without conducting a major search. Whether you’re looking to hire for your internship program or seeking a new employee to fill an entry-level position, collaborating with schools can simplify the recruitment process.
Search for candidates on social media
For a more proactive approach to recruitment, search social media for candidates with relevant expertise who align with your values and company culture. Social media is more embedded in daily life than ever, with the average user spending over two hours per day across a range of platforms from photo-sharing apps to niche, interest-based communities. By conducting targeted searches using relevant keywords and hashtags, your small business can reach potential candidates where they spend most of their time.
Browse industry-specific forums
While unconventional, industry-specific forums can be a powerful way to connect with candidates genuinely interested in your company's work. By exploring reputable forums where thoughtful, in-depth discussions take place, you can engage with individuals who already have a strong understanding of your industry and a clear desire to grow within it. Their active participation outside the workplace demonstrates a genuine interest in and connection to the field, making these spaces a natural starting point for identifying and building relationships with motivated talent.
Create a recruitment marketing engine
At its core, recruitment marketing is about employing marketing strategies to promote your open roles and company and attract the right talent. As a recruiter, you’re selling a job — and recruitment marketing is how you connect to the right “buyer,” or future employee.
To build a strong recruitment engine, focus on how your company is perceived externally. Leverage key marketing tools and channels — including your website, job boards, and social media — to draw candidates in and amplify your core message. Start by ensuring your website and social media accurately reflect your workplace and that your job descriptions align with your company’s tone and values.
Consider leveraging recruitment software and agencies to streamline your screening process and facilitate smoother communication with candidates and internal teams. If your budget allows, working with a recruitment agency can give you access to their existing talent pool, expand your company’s reach, and speed up the hiring process.
[Read more: A Strategic Guide to Marketing Your Small Business]
Measure and refine your KPIs
To understand what’s working — and what isn’t — monitor your hiring efforts by measuring and refining key performance indicators (KPIs). While recruitment metrics often track how quickly open roles fill, they become more valuable when viewed through a talent acquisition lens. Instead of treating metrics like short-term measurements tied to individual hires, track them over time to identify trends and support long-term workforce planning.
To do so, identify KPIs that offer insight into both your hiring efficiency and candidate quality, then review them regularly to uncover patterns and opportunities for improvement. These metrics may include:
- Time to fill. This KPI helps balance hiring speed with quality, ensuring your process moves quickly without sacrificing due diligence.
- Candidate experience. This figure ensures your hiring process is on par with competitors. Poor candidate experiences can make it harder for companies to find and hire quality candidates.
- Cost per hire. This number reveals how much recruitment resources are allocated, signaling issues of under- or overspending.
- Offer acceptance rate. This figure highlights how well your compensation, role expectations, and overall process align with candidates' needs.
- Source of hire. This insight shows which channels consistently produce strong candidates and can also indicate employee satisfaction when referrals are high.
Looking for more tips on hiring for your small business? Check out our guide on hiring the best employees.
CO— aims to bring you inspiration from leading respected experts. However, before making any business decision, you should consult a professional who can advise you based on your individual situation.
CO—is committed to helping you start, run and grow your small business. Learn more about the benefits of small business membership in the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, here.
